Pop music tops charts when it comes to driving

11.59 | 29 May 2019 | | 4 comments

Listening to pop music creates ‘the perfect atmosphere for smooth and controlled driving’, a new study has found.

The study, carried out by IAM RoadSmart and Auto Express, set out to discover the effects of different types of music on driving style and safety.

While pop music was deemed to have a positive effect, negative connotations were associated with listening to classical and heavy metal music – with the latter causing motorists to ‘lose their cool’ behind the wheel.

The study saw Auto Express consumer reporter, Tristan Shale-Hester, undertake two simulated laps of the Red Bull Ring in Austria while listening to songs from four different genres of music – thrash metal, hip-pop, classical and pop – at full volume.

The two-lap test involved fast acceleration, a series of ‘technically challenging’ corners and a speed-limited zone, completed by a controlled stop on the finish line at the end of the second lap.

Listing to ‘(sic)’ by heavy-metal band Slipknot, IAM RoadSmart head of technical policy Tim Shallcross found Tristan’s throttle movements to be ‘far more jagged’ – while Tristan admitted the song made it harder to concentrate on the circuit layout.

Meanwhile, listening Bach’s Goldberg Variations ‘encouraged too much relaxation’ – leading Tristan to drop his speed to just 35mph in a 50mph zone, without noticing.

‘Humble’ by hip-hop artist Kendrick Lamar caused Tristan to overshoot the finish line by four car lengths – a potentially dangerous 60-70ft – while the laps set listening to ‘Shake It Off’ by Taylor Swift were found to be the ‘smoothest in terms of speed consistency’.

Tim Shallcross said: “What is clear is that the ferocious thrash metal really reduced the ability of the driver to get around the track smoothly.

“That, and high-energy dance music, are designed to be felt as well as heard, and to be listened to at volume. It’s clear neither help when it comes to making exacting driving manoeuvres.

“Volume is the major factor for concentration and has a big effect. I would certainly advise drivers to dial down the noise when making a manoeuvre – and save the thrash metal for later in the day, or night!”

Steve Fowler, editor-in-chief of Auto Express said: “This research shows that as well as making a conscious decision to put their phone away when driving, motorists should also think carefully about what music they listen to.

“While heavy metal was clearly linked to Tristan’s worst lap, classical music fans may be interested to learn that some pieces appear to promote too deep a state of relaxation to be listened to when behind the wheel.”


 

Comments

Comment on this story

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Report a reader comment

Order by Latest first | Oldest first | Highest rated | Lowest rated

    This ‘study’ makes those Loreal hair product surveys look scientifically legit.


    Andy, Derby
    Agree (5) | Disagree (0)
    +5

    Are IAM RoadSmart really that desperate to get their name out there that they release a report and study based on one driver.

    Very similar to their video suggesting that their ECO fleet driving course could produce 55% fuel savings. When the 55% savings was actually based on only one driver (from March 2017http://roadsafetygb.org.uk/news/new-video-highlights-dangers-of-driving-for-work-5650/). Which they eventually agreed was misleading.

    Actually surprised that RSGB published the article.


    Keith
    Agree (12) | Disagree (1)
    +11

    This study doesn’t account to exposure either. Someone who listens to high intensity “thrash metal” with regularity is arguably less likely to be as distracted or as affected by it.

    To further my comment above, it seems that people who are regular listeners to extreme metal music are more likely to be calmed by it; https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2015/06/22/heavy-metal-extreme-music-calmer_n_7636534.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly9jb25zZW50LnlhaG9vLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAAHWbWSHVVe-JOIe69QChzLJf-RXIEiY8mGY1RmNeRiFZbN56BxUF5IXAqE35p6KIpjD5REHsyWHOlB5e_FWQPgtcCeAi-R0Q0USH-r0f0iOxncqxvovReh5zw-8D_l4t53XB-IUw1gNUXx-0P0GF3IEMdpjWieu3efNx9MvjLjdj

    Might I suggest the nation takes up the likes of Iron Maiden as a favourite artist to help deal with potential Road Rage situations? 😉


    James Fee, Nottingham
    Agree (7) | Disagree (0)
    +7

    A test based on one driver’s response is hardly ‘research’ nor ‘a new study’.


    Hugh Jones, Cheshire
    Agree (16) | Disagree (1)
    +15