E-scooters: casualty stats and the strive for accuracy

11.13 | 8 December 2021 | | 2 comments

With trials of rental e-scooters now commonplace in many towns and cities, and the future use of their privately-owned counterparts set for debate in 2022, the safety implications of this emerging, yet controversial, mode of transport remains heavily scrutinised.

For the first time in September 2021, the DfT published statistics showing the number of casualties in collisions involving e-scooters.

The figures, which cover rental and privately-owned e-scooters, highlight that during 2020 there were 460 collisions involving e-scooters, resulting in a total of 484 casualties.

Figures are also now available for the 12-months to June 2021, showing 931 casualties.

While nearly doubling, the increase shouldn’t come as a surprise, given that the first rental trials only got underway in July 2020 – with many more following since, including the largest in London in June 2021.

The DfT acknowledges that it is “not yet able to fully assess the quality of the e-scooter data captured in STATS19, in terms of consistency of recording practice for e-scooters across different police force areas, so data should be treated with caution.”

In other words, the figures are ‘drastically’ under-reported.

So says the National Federation of the Blind UK (NFBUK), who is highlighting the issue as part of its long-standing and vociferous campaign against the use of e-scooters.

NFBUK points to statistics published by the Parliamentary Advisory Council for Transport Safety (PACTS) as part of an ongoing research project to assess the safety of private e-scooters.

The project is gathering data of casualties involving private e-scooters (riders and other road users) collected from the media, police forces and at least one major trauma centre.

The figures show that at three A&E departments in Bristol there were 90 e-scooter related injuries during a four-week period in May/June 2021 – equating to 3.2 patients a day.

However, the DfT data shows that Avon and Somerset Police only reported 21 e-scooter casualties for the six-month period January-June 2021.

Moreover, nearly 20% of those who attended one the Bristol A&E departments suffered head injuries – with three patients sustaining severe traumatic brain injury, intracranial haemorrhage or a skull fracture.

Sarah Gayton, street access campaign coordinator at the NFBUK, said: “These figures are terrifying.

“It appears the price for the e-scooter trial in Bristol – and allowing the ongoing use of illegal e-scooters on the streets – is being paid by those who are now living with life changing injuries.

“This has to stop; the accident rate is horrific and this should make the (Bristol) council take immediate action to halt the trial.

“It should also be a wake-up call for the Government to take action to stop the shops selling private ones.

“No more time is required to trial them; they should never be legalised and the sooner they are off the streets the better for everyone.”

However, work is ongoing to improve the situation.

The DfT says in future, e-scooter casualties will be better captured as part of a new ‘powered personal transporter’ category – being introduced as part of a recent STATS19 review.

The DfT is also liaising with PACTS as part of their project.

David Davies, executive director of PACTS, said: “The DfT data is from police STATS19 reports.

“It is well established that casualties not involving a motor vehicle tend to be particularly under-reported. Whereas the Bristol hospital data showed 70% of e-scooters casualties did not involve another motor vehicle – the DFT data recorded only 20%.

“Meanwhile, the DfT (e-scooter data) factsheet reports three deaths in the year to June 2021 – whereas PACTS has been notified of five. This may be due to lags in police reports or because some may have happened off the highway.

“The DfT is working with PACTS to compare data sets and better understand the overall situation.”


 

Comments

Comment on this story

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Report a reader comment

Order by Latest first | Oldest first | Highest rated | Lowest rated

    > Figures are also now available for the 12-months to June 2021, showing 931 casualties

    About 15,000 cyclists are injured every year. Shall we take bold action and ban cyclists too for public health reasons?


    David Weston, Newcastle upon Tyne
    Agree (0) | Disagree (6)
    --6

    “Casualty” should be re-defined to mean either physical or mental injury. Statistics should include all the casualties that are ignored i.e. the life-changing mental traumas of accumulative countless near misses that render disabled and elderly people too afraid to go out – unless they use a taxi. I am a pensioner and have a mobility disability. I am trapped in my house after dark as these scooters (and bikes) illegally zoom along the pavements. It’s bad enough in daylight but in the dark they cannot be seen. E-scooters are forcing walkers into taxis, thus contributing to climate change

    I try to report the numerous inappropriately ridden e-scooters to the police so that they are aware of their prevalence. I also report the rental scooters to VOI. It takes ages to get through to the Police 101 number, so I report them via the “Tell us about something else” page on the police website as the police advised me. VOI send me a template response when I submit a complaint to them. They address me as “Hey” and sign of by telling me to “Have an amazing day!” or “Scoot scoot!” inspite of my complaining that their out of control scooters terrify me daily! They should be banned.


    Christina Young, Liverpool
    Agree (9) | Disagree (0)
    +9

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close